Welcome to the Gumboot Bloggeroo! You won't get many hits from the Top 40 here - more like misses from the Back 40. Proudly behind the times, I perform traditional and not-so-traditional music from the East Coast of Canada - songs and tunes, with harmonica, fiddle, guitar, piano, and whatever else is on hand. Check out the samples, the pictures, the information, the misinformation, the free advice, the second-hand opinions, and whatever else I end up dumping here ....

Saturday 26 May 2012

Seems that grumbling about cultural appropriation/misrepresentation/misappropriation in showbiz is nothing new, no more than the Irish pipes standing in for Highland (as in Braveheart) - from the aforementioned article:


One newspaper correspondent, styling himself ‘The Ghost of
Carolan’ and complaining about Courtney’s stage costume in Oscar
and Malvina, incidentally confirms his nationality and that of his
pipes:
As an Irishman, give me leave to observe, that in the representation
of Oscar and Malvina the Irish pipes are introduced; but why the
piper should be habited in a Highland dress, I cannot reconcile to
my feelings... Now, by my shoul, I tink an Irishman playing so well
upon the pipes as little C——y, should not be ashamed of his
brogues, and let the music give his Scotch bonnet the lie.

(1791)

jt

No comments:

Post a Comment